Two Flavors. One Trick. You Decide.
Welcome tothe Test Ride
Taste Sticky S'mores and Cinnamon Sugar, then vote for your fave.
How Test Ride Works
A flavor election, decided by the only voters who matter: the people with a knife in the jar.
- 1
Taste the Test Ride
Two limited flavors arrive together. Spread, scoop, sandwich — try them every way you like.
- 2
Cast your vote
Scan the code in your order and vote for your champion. Watch the ponies race in real time.
- 3
One gets a shot at forever
The winner gets the opportunity to become a permanent flavor. The other may never return!!!!!
- 2flavors in the Test Ride
- 1chance at permanent status
- 100%ingredients you can pronounce
Get to Know Each Flavor
August drop: Sticky S'mores and Cinnamon Sugar. Taste both in the Test Ride, then vote. One gets the opportunity to become a permanent flavor.
Sticky S'mores
Chocolate melted into PB, graham flavor, crunchy marshmallows.
Flavor #01 in the Test Ride lineup: chocolate melted into the peanut butter base, graham cracker flavor, and crunchy marshmallows swirled in. A s'more you can spread on everything.
Ingredients
Organic roasted Argentinian peanuts and salt, chocolate, graham cracker flavor, crunchy marshmallows. Contains peanuts.
- ✓No-shoulder jar so your knife glides clean to the corners
- ✓Upside-down storage keeps the natural oil ready to stir
- ✓Wide mouth for easy, mess-free scooping
The Race Is On
Two ponies. Two flavors. One shot at permanent status. Every Test Ride vote moves a pony down the track.
Test Ride Derby
now racing
Standings update as Test Rides ship · Sticky S'mores is out front
Questions, Answered
Everything you need to know before you taste and vote.
Test Ride is our flavor election. You grab the Test Ride with both limited flavors, taste them, and vote for your favorite. The winner gets the opportunity to become a permanent flavor.
Nope. Test Ride comes as a 2-jar bundle on purpose. You get both experimental flavors, try them side by side, and vote for the one that deserves to become permanent. One jar means no comparison, and no comparison means no vote. Democracy runs on duos. 🥄
Every Test Ride comes with a code to cast your vote. One vote per order. Watch the live race on this page to see which pony is pulling ahead.
The race runs for a limited time only. We'll announce the winning flavor the moment the finish line is crossed — subscribers hear first.
Organic roasted Argentinian peanuts and salt, plus each flavor's signature add-ins. No junk. Full ingredients for each jar are in Get to Know Each Flavor.
Our peanut butter is processed in a facility that also produces tree nuts. Contains peanuts.
They're a limited run. Losing flavors may come back later as an LTO — this round is about who earns the opportunity to become a permanent flavor.
Free on orders over $60. Your Test Ride ships fast so you can taste, vote, and start lobbying your friends.
The Test Ride
Sticky S'mores and Cinnamon Sugar in one box. Taste them, vote for your favorite, and help decide who gets the opportunity to become a permanent flavor.
- ✓2 limited August flavors
- ✓1 vote to crown the winner
- ✓Free shipping on orders over $60
Limited August drop · once it's gone, it's gone
Pony People Agree
Real reviews from onetrickponynuts.com — 5.0 from hundreds of verified buyers.
Swipe to read more →